Cultural Bias in the Perception of Foreign-Policy Events
by Felix S. Bethke
Global Cooperation Research Papers 14, Duisburg 2016
Cultural bias means individuals judge and interpret a phenomenon according to values that are inherent in their own culture. The same event may be perceived differently by individuals with different cultural backgrounds. This study systematically tests for the presence of cultural differences in the perception of foreign policy events. Using a web survey with a split-sample of Chinese and US foreign policy experts, four domains of foreign policy are explored: sanctions; border violations; foreign aid; and trade agreements. The findings indicate general agreement between Chinese and US experts in the classification of foreign-policy events as cooperative, neutral, or conflictive. In regard to more specific foreign-policy scenarios, the picture is more differentiated. In the case of economic sanctions and border violations, there appears, again, to be general agreement as to the degree of conflictiveness of these events. In addition, perception does not appear to be influenced by collective self-esteem, in the sense that responses remain similar whether the event is described in abstract or country-specific terms. In the case of trade agreements and foreign aid, by contrast, there is a divergence in Chinese and US perceptions in regard to contextual factors such as conditionality and enforcement. Overall, the study suggests that while culture rarely
affects the general perception of foreign-policy events, it does play a role in the perception of more complex concepts, such as conditionality and enforcement, that structure the context and meaning of those events.
Keywords: Cultural bias, international cooperation, international conflict, foreign policy, event perception
Felix S. Bethke is a postdoc scholar in the Department of International Relations and Development Policy at the University of Duisburg-Essen. He was previously a postdoc fellow at the Käte Hamburger Kolleg / Centre for Global Cooperation Research at the University of Duisburg-Essen. His research interests are African Politics, Peace & Conflict Studies, Foreign Policy, and Sociology of Science. His work has been published
in Journal of Comparative Governance and Politics, Journal of International Relations and Development, and Journal of Peace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy.